Home » Eyeliner » Best Eyeliner – Cake, Organic, Powder, Long Lasting, Smudge Free, Gel, Pencil, Semi, Permanent Eyeliners

Best Eyeliner – Cake, Organic, Powder, Long Lasting, Smudge Free, Gel, Pencil, Semi, Permanent Eyeliners

We may earn a commission when you purchase via links on this page. See our affiliate disclosure.

Are you wondering what is the best eyeliner?  We’ve got the answer for you. This article has the best cake, organic, powder, long lasting or best smudge free, liquid, gel, waterproof, pencil, semi, permanent and best glitter eyeliners. It is true, there are many types and many people often get confused on what to go for. Get the best brands in different categories as well as the best or top brands in each category.

Best Eyeliners - Waterproof Eyelieners

This is going to be a lengthy discussion with many best eyeliner brands covered on each category or type of eyeliners we are going to cover. At the end of it all, you should be able to tell the best powder, liquidcreamglitter, cake, pencil, long lasting, organic among many others. Stay put and checkout the various types of eye liners and some of their best eyeliner brands in each type or compare prices of the best brands

1. Powder Eyeliner

Powder eyeliners are versatile and they will help you look dramatic as you define your eyes and make precise and perfect curves. These eye liner come in powder form and often applied using preferably an angled eyeliner brush either dry or when dampened.

When a damped brush is used, they last longer than dry ones. The proces

s of applying them is similar to other types (see how to apply eyeliner for details). Powder eyeliners come in many colors and shades. You have the freedom of choose from deeply pigmented, soft ones to jewel toned brands. There are also many brands of powdered eyeliners, which include the following

Best Powder Eyeliner – Top Brands

Best Eyeliners – Powder Eyeliners
Powder Eyeliners

If you are excited by the best powder eyeliner and you want to try them out, here are some of best eyeliner brands that come in powdered form:

  • Smashbox Soft Effects Powder  Eyeliner Gunmetal
  • Wear Infinité® Soft Powder Eye Liner
  • Smoky Eyes Powder Pencil
  • Guerlain Terracotta Loose Powder Kohl Liner
  • Trish McEvoy Eye Definer/ Eye Liner
  • No7 Smokey Powder Eye Liner
  • L’Oreal Minerals Kohl Powder
  • L’Oreal Paris Wear Infinite Soft Powder Eye Liner
  • essence I Love Glam Powder  and Eye Shadow
  • Sudi’s Sormeh Powder
  • Jane Iredale cream to powder
  • Jane Iredale mystikol powdered and highlighter
  • Smashbox Soft Effects Powder Eye Liner

The above list of best powder eye liners in powder form is endless. If you do not find your favorite powder eyeliner in this list, you have nothing to worry you. Furthermore, read various powder eyeliner reviewscustomer rating and comments before selecting a certain top brand. Do not forget to choose the right color since they come in different colors.

2. Cake Eyeliner

Cake eyeliners are among great brands much known for their long lasting and dramatic versatile appeal they give. They are nothing other than pressed powders that are highly pigmented. They are often applied using a damp eye liner brush. Depending on your skill level, you could get from a natural to sophisticated and hilarious looks. Some type of cake eyeliner could be water activated.

Application of cake eyeliner is just as in the case of any applying any other eyeliner. You need to dip a damp brush onto the cake eyeliner or roll it. When applying, mild pressure will yield to thinner lines while much pressure means you will get thicker lines.

Best Cake Eyeliner – Top Brands

If you have never used it before, there are many kinds of best cake eyeliner brands available in the market. Of course, like other types types,  they come in many different colors. Some of the best brands you can go for include the following:

Best Eyeliners - Cake Eyeliners
Cake Eyeliners
  • Laura Mercier Tightline Cake Eye Liner
  • kryolan cake
  • napoleon perdis cake
  • La Femme Cake Sealer
  • High-Definition Cake
  • Kohl Cake Liner
  • Femme Couture Mineral Effects Baked Cake
  • Coloressence Cake
  • Illamasqua Mislead Cake
  • Ben Nye Cake Eye Liner

The above list does not have everything. We only listed the few best cake eyeliners we could find, test and research on. There are many other different types of cake eyeliners, which have not been included in our list, which are equally good or even better. Conduct an independent research before buying any of the best cake eyeliner since it might not be the best.

3. Organic Best Eyeliners

Among the best eyeliner gaining popularity to people conscious of ingredients are the organic ey eliners. For those who might not be aware of these types of eyeliners, it is good to understand what they are in the first place. Organic eyeliner are type of eyeliner whose raw materials are derived from plants only.

Alternatively, the term could be used to mean eye liners made from compounds that are naturally occurring, including minerals. If you buy any eyeliner labeled organic, it means that the materials used are certified as organic and were not exposed to any other chemicals such as pesticides. Unless eye liner is labeled as certified organic, it might contain some pesticides.

From the above explanation, it should be clear that organic eyeliner are more to do with their ingredients than form or type. Therefore, there are different type and forms of this makeup as they could be powder, cake, liquid, glitter, permanent eyeliner, and so on.

The Best Organic Eyeliner – Top Brands

Many companies and manufacturers claim they have the best organic eyeliner. Some of the best organic eyeliners, which are truly or certified organic eyeliners, include the following:

Best Eyeliners - Organic Eyeliners or Natural Eyeliners
Organic or Natural Eyeliners
  • Organic wear™ 100% Natural Origin
  • Mineral Wear™ Talc-Free Mineral Eye Liner Pencil
  • Organic Cake by NVEY Eco
  • Lavera
  • Josie Maran
  • Midnight Mineral Eye Liner
  • Oak Mineral Eye Liner
  • NVEY ECO’s High-Definition Cake – Organic Cake
  • Vapour Organic Beauty’s Mesmerize Smokey Eye Tool
  • Inika Organic Duo
  • Terra d’Oc – Kohl Liner
  • Organic Glam – Mineral Eye Pencil
  • UNE – Absolute Blacks Kohl

If your best eyeliner brand, which is organic in nature, did not appear in the above list, it does not mean it is not certified organic. The above names are simply some of the popular brands. It is time you should go organic if you are conscious of your health and you want to avert some of the possible side effects of non-organic eyeliners. Also, read organic eyeliner reviews, ratings and customer feedback if you want to get some of the best brands.

4. Long Lasting Best Eyeliner – Smudge Free

Long lasting eyeliners is not a type or special category. They are the best eye liners, which have a tendency of staying in place for a long duration of time. One unique feature that these eye liners have is that they do not smudge or smear easily when exposed to normal environmental conditions. How to wear long lasting eyeliner is depended on their type and form. You could have powdered, cake, organic, gel, pencil, glitter, liquid and many other forms of these eye liners. However, it will follow the usual procedure for applying eyeliners.

If you tried some of the highly publicized long lasting eyeliner, you might be disappointed because not all of them are long lasting. There are few, which truly prevent greasy creases, smears and smudges even in humid and hot temperatures. So, what are some of the best eyeliners that are long lasting?

Best Long Lasting Eyeliner – Top Brands

If you want some of the tested and proven long lasting eyeliner, then the list below will give you some of the best eyeliner that will last for a whole day without smear, smudge or color migration.

Best Eyeliners - Long Lasting Eyeliner
Long Lasting Eye liner
  • Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eye Pencil
  • Urban Decay 24/7 Waterproof Liquid
  • NARS Larger Than Life Long-Wear
  • Revlon ColorStay Eyeline
  • Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes
  • Le Stylo Waterproof Eye Makeup
  • Kat Von D Tattoo Liner
  • Almay Liquid Liner (Various Colors – This is Brown)
  • Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel
  • arte emphasEYES
  • Chanel Stylo Yeux Waterproof Long-Lasting
  • NYX Super Skinny Eye Marker
  • Lancome Le Stylo Waterproof Long Lasting

The list of the best long lasting eyeliner is endless. The above is a representation of some of the best eyeliner that lasts long and/or popular and not necessarily the only ones. You did not see your favorite long lasting eyeliner? There is no need to worry so long as it can last for at least 12 hours without smudging, flaking or fading.

5. Semi Permanent Best Eyeliner

Best Eyeliners - Semi Permanent Eyeliners
Semi Permanent Eyeliners

Imagine the struggle of having to wake up every morning to apply eyeliners or after you shower, go swimming or when your makeup smudges. You can say goodbye to all this hassle with semi-permanent makeup, they are among the best brands that are gaining popularity amongst many people. Some of the benefits of semi permanent makeup are similar to the ones of permanent ey eliner.

Semi permanent eyeliners can be looked at in two ways. One is a scenario where eyeliners are placed under the dermal skin layer. They are often oxides of iron where you preferred color is implanted below your skin on the upper and lower lashes and will remain intact for a period ranging from two to five years.

This kind of semi permanent eyeliners can be done by either makeup technicians or doctors in the cosmetic field. Depending on the expertise of the person who did it, you could achieve a natural or dramatic look, depending on what pleases you. The procedure is more or less the same as that one of permanent eyeliner.

The other way of looking at semi-permanent liners is as those eye liners, which last for up to 24 hours. They are often sold in pen form where the user can apply them on the upper and lower eyelashes and they will remain intact for 24 hours. They are ideal when you are in a tight schedule and you might not have time to reapply your eyeliners again. In this case, eyeliners used are similar to those of long lasting eyeliners.

Note: We have covered the issue of semi permanent eyeliners also knows as tattooed eyeliner comprehensively including their benefits, dangers, procedures in details.

6. Waterproof Best Eyeliners

Another category of the best eyeliner are the waterproof eye liner. They are at times referred to as water resistant eyeliners and they do not smudge, smear or migrates if water is splashed on the face. They are suitable for people who have watery eyes or during a humid season.

Most of the waterproof eyeliner can stay put for a whole day without undergoing much degradation or fading away. If you are interested read more about waterproof eyeliner, some of the best waterproof eyeliners, their pros and cons, and much more.

Best Waterproof Eyeliners – Top Brands

To help you quickly choose the brands from this category, below is a list of some of what many people have found very useful. The list is not conclusive as many best waterproof eyeliners that could also be included exist.

  • Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid
  • Stýli-Style Line and Seal 24 Twist
  • Napoleon Perdis Neo Noir Liquid Liner
  • Pixi Endless Silky Eye Pen
  • Wet n Wild H20 Proof Liquid Eye Liner
  • Clarins Waterproof  Pencil 1.4g
  • Sephora Collection Retractable Waterproof
  • NYC New Your Color Waterproof Pencil
  • Swimmables Waterproof Pencil
  • e.l.f. Waterproof Pen
  • LORAC 3-In-1Waterproof  Pencil

Not to overemphasis, the list best eyeliners in this category are long and if you do not notice your favorite brand here, it does not mean you leave it. Also read best waterproof eyeliner reviews, customer ratings and comments before settling on any brand.

7. Pencil Eyeliner

Eyeliner pencils are the oldest kind of eye liner every to be used by humankind. As their name suggests, there are pencil shaped eyeliners, which glides easily when applying them. Different brands vary slightly. Some pencil eyeliner need to be sharpened while others do not need to be sharpened.

Of course, they are the best eyeliners for newbie or beginners and they come in many amazing colors to choose from and could give you both natural and dramatic looks. Some makeup artists claim that they do not give deep colors as in the case of liquid eyeliner. To get insight on pencil eyeliner, their pros, cons, and how to use them read exclusively on Pencil Eye liners – Pros, Cons, and How to Apply them

Best Pencil Eyeliner – Top Brands

You definitely want to know some of the best brands in this category. The list below contains some of the trending.

Best Eyeliners - Pencil Eyeliners
Pencil Eyeliners
  • MAC Eye Kohl Pencil
  • MAC Chromagraphic Pencils
  • L’Oreal HIP Chrome
  • Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyes
  • Maybeline Unstoppable ONYX
  • Revlon colorstay
  • Avon Glimmerstick waterproof
  • SEPHORA COLLECTION Liner Electro – Glitter Eye Pencil
  • Milani Glitzy Eyes Retractable Glitter Pencil
  • Avon Glimmersticks Blackest Night  Pencil Black
  • NYX Cosmetics Slim Pencil Eye Liner 9pc Glitter Eye Liner Pencils
  • Urban Decay 24/7
  • Jumbo pencils

The above list is only a representative of some of the pencil eyeliners you could go for. It might not mean they are necessary the best eyeliners you should go for blindly. Read best pencil eye liner reviews, see how they are rated, what users say and know the colors they come in before investing in this types of eyeliners.

8. Permanent Eyeliner or Tattooed Eyeliner

best Eyeliners - Permanent Eyeliner or Tattooed Eyeliner
Permanent or Tattooed Eyeliner

Imagine if you had beautiful permanent eyeliners, which require no more makeup. This sounds great doesn’t it huh? With the permanent eyeliners, you have a chance to look either natural or dramatic. They are also known as tattooed eyeliner where a tattooing procedure is used on your eyelashes to enhance their appearance.

This permanent pigmentation procedure involves using various techniques and specialized machines to introduced desired color pigments under the lash line skin. It might also involve increasing the eyelashes for people who have thin, few or lost them because of one or the other reason.

Wait a moment, being a permanent procedure; you should be informed about it before you go for it. It can be removed but the process is very painful. Do you need to know more about permanent eyeliner, their benefits, risks, dangers, and much more? Visit Permanent Eyeliner, to learn more about their pros, risks, procedures, and much more.

9. Glitter Eyeliner

Do you want to make your evening glamorous with stunning eyeliners that will make everyone staring at you? Glitter eyeliner should be your number one choice of eyeliner. When done well and matched properly with other attire, they can be nerve-racking. However, if done poorly, you stand a chance of looking like a clown if not a disco ball waiting for music and dancers!

Glitter eyeliners are among the best eyeliner for people with anniversaries, birthdays and other events. They contain micro particles, which can transform your appearance since they glitter. They are simply the brands for an eventful evening. Learn some secrets and tips for success with glitter eye liners, their pros, cons, and how to apply them like a diva by reading exclusively on Glitter Eye liners

Best Glitter Eye liner – Top Brands

Many brands and colors of glitter eyeliners do exist. It all depends on your expertise at using them, the event you are wearing them to and your taste. Here are some of the best glittery eyeliner: 

Best Eyeliners - Glitter Eyeliners
Glitter Eyeliners
  • NYX Studio Effect Liquid Crystal
  • Bobbi Brown Glitter Liquid Eye Liner SILVER
  • Milani Glitzy Eyes Retractable Glitter  Pencil
  • SEPHORA COLLECTION Liner Electro – Glitter Eye Pencil
  • 12 LA Colors Shimmer Sparking Glitter Eye Liner Set
  • Victoria’s Secret ‘Beauty Rush’ PURPLE POP Glitter Eye Gel
  • NYX Cosmetics Slim Pencil Eye Liner 9pc Glitter Eye Liner Pencils
  • Victoria’s Secret Brilliant Glitter Liquid Liner – Mirrorball
  • Zink Color Gold Leaf Flake Elegant Eye Body Makeup
  • Avon Solutions Plus+ Total Radiance Eye Gel
  • Beauty Treats Long Lasting Smooth Glitter Liquid 6 pcs Set

This list should not intimidate you as it only contains some of the popular brands of glitter eyeliner and not necessarily the best only. Whatever glitter eyeliner you are using could be better. Again, before switching to any of the best eyeliner brands above, ask yourself if have research by reading glitter eyeliner reviews, ratings and customer comments. This can help you know if you are making the right decision or not.

10. Liquid Eyeliners

Liquid eyeliners are eyeliner, which come in liquid form. Although a bit difficult to use and need some exercise before they can be used, they are among the best eyeliner for people who want to get best lash lines that are highly visible. If you would like to try them, you need to learn more about them. We have an article on this eyeliners where you are going to be introduced to them, know their pros and cons, how to use them as well as some secrets, tips and advice of ensuring you are successful with liquid eyeliners.

The Best Liquid Eyeliners – Top Rated Brands

Are you looking for the best eyeliners that are in liquid form? Below is a long list that represents some of the popular or best liquid eyeliners. The list is not inclusive. Do you own independent research on each of the best liquid eyeliner listed below before investing money on them.

  • Urban Decay Liquid Liner

    Best Eyeliners - Glitter Eyeliners
    Glitter Eyeliners
  • Lancome Artliner Eye-liner
  • NARS  Stylos
  • Revlon Colorstay Liquid Liner
  • L’Oreal Paris Telescopic Precision Liquid
  • Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
  • The Smashbox Limitless Liquid Liner Pen
  • Maybelline Line Stiletto Ultimate Precision Liquid
  • Smashbox Limitless Liquid Liner Pen
  • Benefit Cosmetics Magic Ink Liquid
  • Koji Dolly Wink Liquid
  • Prestige Liquid

11.Gel/Cream Eyeliner

Finally, on the eyeliner types, we have the gel eyeliner. They are also called cream eyeliner as they come in form of a cream or gel. They are very simple to apply as they easily glide and they could be used to achieve whatever look you want. They are gaining popularity to many people. To learn more on gel eyeliners, their pros and cons as well as how to apply gel eyeliner, visit Gel Eyeliner/Cream Eyeliner. However, for the sake of letting you know, we are going to look at the best gel or cream eye liners.

Best Gel/ Cream Eyeliners

There are many manufactures and brands of the so-called gel or cream eyeliners. You are at liberty to go for what works best for you. Some of the best eyeliner that come in gel or cream forms include the following:

Best Eyeliners - Gel Eyeliners or Cream Eyeliner
Gel or Cream Eyeliners
  • Loreal Hip Creme
  • Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel
  • Inglot Matte Collection AMC Gel
  • Studio Gear Invincible Gel Cream Eye Color.
  • Shu Uemura Painting Liner
  • Make Up For Ever Aqua Creamliner
  • Smashbox Jet Set Waterproof
  • Shiseido The Makeup Accentuating Cream
  • Make Up For Ever Aqua Creamliner
  • Cle de Peau Beaute Intensifying Cream
  • Yves Saint Laurent Effet Faux Cils Longwear Cream
  • Estee Lauder Double Wear Stay-In-Place Gel

Before investing money on gel or cream eyeliner, do your part. Ensure you read online reviews on gel eyeliners, ratings and see user observations. This will ensure you go for the best brands in this category and not lured by the powerful advertisements used to promote them.


This has no doubt been a very length discussion. It is however very important since it has quickly summarized some of the best eyeliner in various categories. Not everything has been covered here; we chose a few of the popular types of eyeliner and gave some of their best brands.

Also See Popular Eyeliner Colors

Also See Popular Eyeliner Types

Also See General on Eyeliners

Which eyeliner brand and type works best for you? Warn, Advice or Share!

Leave Your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *.